The 8 best cotton nursing bras on Amazon

Most nursing bras are made of synthetic material that can be very good quality and feel great on the skin.

But let’s not forget good old cotton. Environmental benefits aside, cotton nursing bras feel baby-soft on sore nipples and tender breasts. They are also absorbent and breathable, reducing your risk of irritation and rash.

Further reading: Should nursing bras be cotton?

Plus, there are some really good quality yet affordable cotton nursing bras on the market. Check these out:

Best overall cotton nursing bra: Kindred Bravely Extra Soft Organic Cotton Nursing Bra

Check it out on Amazon

Why I like the KB Extra Soft Organic Cotton Nursing Bra

• It ticks all the right boxes – it’s comfy, supportive and affordable.
• It’s made of organic cotton, which is much better for the environment and for your skin.
• It’s a pull-on style with no hooks or snaps to irritate your skin
• It comes in a great range of sizes, catering for moms with size 30B boobs and upwards. It even comes in busty sizes for larger-breasted moms.
• Comes in 6 pretty colors
• No wonder more than 1000 moms have given it 5-stars on Amazon.

What I don’t like about it

• It can lose elasticity if not washed properly – make sure you wash it in a lingerie bag on delicate cycle.
• Not supportive enough for outside wear.

Best everyday cotton nursing bra: HOTmilk Show Off Nursing Bra

Check it out on Amazon

Why I love the HOTmilk Show Off Nursing Bra

• it’s made of 100% cotton
• Wireless but has a thick under-bust band and strong straps for support
• lightly lined soft cups to absorb milk leaks and prevent nipple show through
• looks smooth under t-shirts and tighter tops
• A frame slings offer better support while breastfeeding, especially if you have large breasts
• 6 hook and eye extensions
• beautiful lace detailing helps me feel more like a woman, not just a milk factory
• larger cups come with wider straps for added support
• comes in sizes 32C up to 42GG

What I don’t like about it

• not all bras in the Show Off range is made of cotton – only the ivory bra, persian leopard print bra (pic above) and navy bra is made of 100% cotton.
• full cups come up quite high, this bra is more suited to moms with larger breasts

Best cotton sleep bra: Motherhood Maternity Wrap Front Sleep Bra

Check it out on Amazon

Why I like the MM Wrap Front Sleep Bra

• It’s made of soft, breathable cotton (95%) with a bit of Spandex thrown in for stretch
• It’s a pull-on design with no irritating wires, hooks or snaps
• The wrap front makes it easy to pull aside the cups when you’re breastfeeding at night
• It’s one of the most popular nursing sleep bras on Amazon
• Holds up well over frequent washings
• Great value-for-money

What I don’t like about it

• Sizes run small so if you’re in between sizes, order a size up.
• If you have a long torso, the bra might be too short for you

Best under-wire cotton nursing bra: HOTMilk Temptation Nursing Bra

Check it out on Amazon

Why I like the Temptation Nursing Bra

• it’s made of 100% cotton
• beautiful lace detailing helps me feel sexy and womanly
• flexi-wired soft cup offer comfy additional support
• encapsulated cups for separation, lift and an amazing silhouette under tight tops
• padded cups absorb milk leaks and prevent nipple show-through
• side sling for side-support during breastfeeding
• normal U straps are convertible to racerback
• top of cups are made to stretch with breast size fluctuations
• fits moms from 30D to 38GG
• comes in powder (pic above), jet black and graphite 

What I don’t like about it

• on the pricier side
• full cups and thick bands overwhelm smaller bodies – definitely much more suitable for bigger girls

Best cotton nursing sports bra: Gratlin Plus Size Racerback Cotton Nursing Sports Bra

Check it out on Amazon

Why I like the Gratlin Racerback Nursing Sports Bra

• one of the very few nursing sports bra around that is made of cotton
• designed specifically for moms with larger boobs up to 48E /50D
• racerback design for better support
• wireless but has a thick underbust band and wide straps for support
• very affordable and great value-for-money
• >2000 5-star ratings on Amazon

What I don’t like about it

• sizes run small so size up
• thin fabric – without removable pads, my nipples poke through under tight workout tops
• not supportive enough for higher impact activities

Best cotton pumping bra: Momcozy Pumping Bra

 Check it out on Amazon

Why I like the Momcozy Pumping Bra

• Fits moms with bra sizes from 30A to 40F/42G
• I can use it for both pumping and breastfeeding
• It uses an ‘X’ structure that holds my bottles and shields in place more securely
• I can wear it as a everyday nursing bra and even to sleep
• Adjustable shoulder straps and comes with extra expanders for better fit and support
• Convertible to racerback style if I want more support
• Compatible with most pump brands: Spectra, Lansinoh, Philips Avent, Evenflo etc.
• Very affordable and great value-for-money
• Number 1 best seller on Amazon with >17,000 5-star ratings!!

What I don’t like about it

• Thin fabric (might be a positive for some)
• Top of bra comes up quite high so I can’t wear this with low-cut tops
• Sizes run big

Best cotton pumping bustier: Simple Wishes Signature Pumping Bra

Check it out on Amazon

Why I like the Simple Wishes Signature Pumping Bra

• It isn’t actually a bra but a bustier that easily slips on over your nursing bra when you want to pump
• One of the few pumping bustiers/corsets around that is made of cotton
• Great value if you already have nursing bras you love and don’t want to buy a dedicated pumping bra
• Fully adjustable 10 inch Velcro back panel to fit you snugly, no matter what size you are
• Fits up to 48J
• Zip-in center panel in the front allows for 1 inch of side-to-side movement for proper positioning of breast pump flanges
• 4-way layering support keeps tight seal of breast shields
• Fits all standard pump flanges from major brands – Medela, Spectra, Philips Avent etc.
• >10,000 5-star ratings on Amazon – it’s one of the most popular pumping bras on Amazon

What I don’t like about it

• I can’t wear it as a bra. That’s unnecessary additional steps at every pump session.
• The velcro wears off over time
• Can unravel at seams with repeated use

Best budget cotton nursing bra: Cakye Nursing Sleep Bra

Check it out on Amazon

Why I like the Cakye Sleep Bra

• It’s super affordable – for less than $30 you get a pack of 3 nursing bras in 3 pretty colors.
• It’s one of the most popular nursing bras on Amazon
• It’s made of soft, breathable cotton with a hint of Spandex for stretch
• The pull-on style means no wires, clasps or hooks to irritate your skin
• Simple cross-over front flaps that you can pull aside easily for night feedings

What I don’t like about it

• The models don’t look like they have ever been pregnant
• It’s too stretchy and not supportive enough. If you have large breasts, don’t buy this
• The lace lining can be scratchy and irritating.
• If you can afford it, choose a better quality nursing bra even if it costs a bit more. You won’t regret spending the extra money.

To wrap up

The best cotton nursing bra of all has to be the Kindred Bravely Extra Soft Organic Cotton Nursing Bra. It ticks all the boxes – it’s supportive, comfy and affordable. Plus it’s organic. The HOTmilk nursing bras make your boobs look good and give you a hint of sexy. And if you are looking for a cotton pumping bra, you have two great choices to choose from – Momcozy pumping bra or the Simple Wishes Signature Pumping Bustier.

With so many natural cotton options to choose from, why buy synthetic?

Check out my review on the best cotton nursing tanks. 

• Author
• Recent Posts

Sharon James

Chief Blogger at The Sensual Mom

I am a mom of 2 bossy toddlers. I breastfed both and struggled through all the usual breastfeeding issues. Now I give nursing moms the info you need to make good decisions during your breastfeeding journey.

Latest posts by Sharon James (see all)

• 17 quick ways to make your husband feel special even when you have no time - June 28, 2022
• How to not lose yourself in motherhood - June 28, 2022
• How soon after birth can you take a bath? - June 11, 2022